Finney Insurance Corporation

The Most Common Causes of Car Accidents in Broward County (And How Insurance Handles Each One)

Causes of Car Accidents in Broward County

Living in Hollywood, Florida, means we get to enjoy beautiful weather and great beaches. But it also means we have to deal with some of the busiest roads in the country. Whether you are driving down I-95 to get to work or heading to the grocery store on US-1, the risk of a car accident is always there. Your car insurance needs to be aligned with your risk. In 2026, Broward County remains one of the top spots in Florida for traffic accidents, with over 36,000 crashes reported in just one year (Source: Injury Lawyers).

Key Takeaways: Broward County Car Accidents

  • High-Traffic Risk: Broward County is one of the most dangerous areas for drivers in Florida, with over 36,000 crashes occurring annually.
  • Common Crash Hotspots: Rear-end collisions are most frequent on I-95 and US-441 due to heavy stop-and-go traffic, while parking lot “fender benders” are common at local hubs like Dania Pointe.
  • The Hit-and-Run Crisis: About 25% of all Florida crashes are hit-and-runs. Because the other driver often cannot be found, having Uninsured Motorist (UM) and Collision coverage is the only way to ensure your bills get paid.
  • Floridas “No-Fault” Rule: Regardless of who caused the accident, your own Personal Injury Protection (PIP) insurance pays for your first $10,000 in medical bills.
  • The “51% Bar” Rule: Florida uses a “Modified Comparative Negligence” system. This means if you are found to be more than 50% at fault for an accident, you cannot collect any money from the other driver’s insurance.
  • Collision vs. Comprehensive: * Collision covers you if you hit another car or an object (like a pole).
    • Comprehensive covers “acts of God” (hurricanes, flooding) and theft/vandalism.
  • Uninsured Motorist (UM) is Vital: With 20% of Florida drivers carrying no insurance at all, UM coverage is your best defense against being stuck with massive medical bills after a crash that wasn’t your fault.

Understanding why these accidents happen and how your insurance works can save you a lot of stress. At Finney Insurance, we want our neighbors to stay safe and informed. In this article, we will look at the main causes of accidents in our area and explain how different insurance coverages help when things go wrong.

Why are there so many rear-end collisions on I-95 and US-441?

Rear-end collisions happen most often on I-95 and US-441 because of heavy “stop-and-go” traffic, high speeds, and drivers following too closely. When traffic suddenly slows down, a driver who is tailgating or not paying attention cannot stop in time, leading to a “fender bender” or a more serious multi-car pileup.

In Broward County, roads like I-95 are constantly packed with commuters. Statistics show that nearly 18% of all crashes in dense urban areas involve one car hitting the back of another (Source: Roselli McNelis). On US-441 (State Road 7), the mix of traffic lights and many business entrances makes it very easy for someone to misjudge a stop.

How Insurance Handles a Rear-End Collision

In Florida, we have “No-Fault” insurance laws. This means your own Personal Injury Protection (PIP) is the first coverage to pay for your medical bills, no matter who caused the crash. PIP usually covers the first $10,000 of your medical costs.

If the other driver hit you from behind, they are usually considered “at fault.” Their Property Damage Liability (PDL) would then pay to fix your car. If your injuries are very bad and cost more than $10,000, you might be able to use the other driver’s Bodily Injury (BI) coverage, if they have it.

Hypothetical Example: Imagine “Kevin” is driving home on US-441. Traffic stops suddenly for a red light near Hollywood Boulevard. The driver behind him is looking at a billboard and hits Kevin’s bumper. Kevin’s PIP pays for his initial doctor visit, and the other driver’s insurance pays the $3,000 bill to fix Kevin’s trunk.

How does distracted driving impact Hollywoods heavy traffic?

Distracted driving is a leading cause of accidents in Hollywood because it takes a drivers eyes and focus off the road during critical moments. Whether it is checking a text message, eating, or adjusting a GPS, even five seconds of distraction while driving 55 mph is like driving the length of a football field blindfolded.

Even though cars in 2026 have more safety features than ever, human distraction is still a major problem. According to the Florida Highway Safety and Motor Vehicles (FLHSMV), distracted driving contributes to thousands of crashes in Broward County every year (Source: Distefano Law). In heavy traffic areas like Sheridan Street or Hollywood Boulevard, things change in a split second. A driver looking at their phone might not see a pedestrian stepping into a crosswalk or a car merging into their lane.

How Insurance Handles Distracted Driving

If a driver is distracted and causes an accident, they are legally responsible for the damages. Their insurance will have to pay for the other person’s car repairs and medical bills through their Liability coverages.

However, if you are the one who was distracted and you hit someone, your insurance rates will likely go up. If you have Collision Coverage, your insurance will pay to fix your car, but you will have to pay your deductible first. If you don’t have Collision coverage, you will have to pay for your own car repairs out of your own pocket.

What makes parking lot accidents so common near our shopping centers?

Parking lot accidents are common near shopping centers like Dania Pointe or Oakwood Plaza because drivers are often distracted by looking for spaces or backing out without seeing other cars. These low-speed crashes happen frequently because drivers assume they are “safe” in a parking lot and may be less careful than they are on the highway.

While these accidents don’t usually cause big injuries, they can cause a lot of damage to your car’s paint and body. In Florida, about 20% of all insurance claims involve some kind of parking lot or low-speed incident (Source: Cohen and Cohen Law).

How Insurance Handles Parking Lot Crashes

Parking lot accidents can be tricky because it is sometimes hard to prove who was at fault. If two cars are backing out at the same time and hit each other, the insurance companies might decide that each driver is 50% at fault.

In this case, Florida’s Modified Comparative Negligence rule applies. This means your insurance company will pay for your repairs based on your percentage of fault. If you are more than 50% at fault, you cannot get money from the other driver’s insurance. This is why having your own Collision Coverage is so important; it protects your car even if the accident was partly your fault.

Why are hit-and-run incidents a major concern in South Florida?

Hit-and-run incidents are a major concern in South Florida because roughly 25% of all crashes in the state involve a driver fleeing the scene. Drivers often run because they are scared, do not have a valid license, or do not have insurance. In 2025, Florida saw over 91,000 hit-and-run crashes (Source: WFTV).

A hit-and-run is a very stressful situation for the victim. You are left with a damaged car and potentially high medical bills, but there is no other driver to hold responsible at the scene. In Broward County, these happen daily on busy stretches of Federal Highway and the Florida Turnpike.

How Insurance Handles a Hit-and-Run

Since there is no other driver’s insurance to pay for your damage, you must rely on your own policy. This is where Uninsured Motorist (UM) Coverage and Collision Coverage become your best friends.

  • Uninsured Motorist (UM): This pays for your medical bills, lost wages, and pain and suffering if the at-fault driver is never found.
  • Collision Coverage: This pays to fix your car after you pay your deductible.

Without these coverages, a hit-and-run could cost you thousands of dollars even though you did nothing wrong.

How does fault work in a Florida car accident claim?

Fault in Florida works through a “No-Fault” system for medical bills and a “Modified Comparative Negligence” system for everything else. First, your own insurance (PIP) pays for your injuries regardless of who caused the crash. Then, for car damage or extra medical costs, the insurance companies look at who was more responsible for the accident.

Starting in 2023, Florida changed the law to say that if you are more than 50% responsible for an accident, you cannot collect any money from the other driver (Source: DHCLAW). This is a “51% bar.”

Hypothetical Example: Imagine “Maria” is turning left and gets hit by “Joe,” who was speeding. An investigator decides Maria was 40% at fault for not waiting, and Joe was 60% at fault for speeding. Since Maria is under the 50% limit, she can collect 60% of her damages from Joe’s insurance. If she had been 51% at fault, she would get nothing from him.

When should I use collision vs. comprehensive coverage?

You should use Collision coverage when your car hits another vehicle or an object, and you should use Comprehensive coverage for non-collision events like theft, storms, or fire. Both coverages are optional in Florida, but they provide “full coverage” protection for the value of your vehicle.

[Image comparing Collision vs. Comprehensive coverage scenarios]

Collision Coverage

This kicks in if you:

  • Hit another car.
  • Hit a tree or a pole.
  • Flip your car over.
  • Are involved in a hit-and-run.

Comprehensive Coverage

This kicks in if your car is damaged by:

  • Theft or Vandalism: Someone steals your car or keys the paint.
  • Nature: A hurricane branch falls on your car, or the street floods during a South Florida summer storm.
  • Animals: You hit a deer or a stray animal on the road.
  • Glass: Your windshield gets a crack from a rock flying off a truck on I-95.

Why is Uninsured Motorist (UM) coverage essential for Broward drivers?

Uninsured Motorist (UM) coverage is essential because about 20% of Florida drivers do not carry any insurance at all. If one of these drivers hits you, they will not have any money to pay for your surgery or your time away from work. UM coverage acts as the insurance that the other driver should have had.

In a crowded county like Broward, the chances of hitting an uninsured driver are quite high. According to the Florida Policy Project, our state has some of the highest insurance rates, which leads many people to drive illegally without a policy (Source: Florida Policy Project). UM coverage follows you, not just your car. It can even protect you if you are walking across the street as a pedestrian and get hit by an uninsured driver.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Does Florida really require “No-Fault” insurance?

Yes. Every driver in Florida must carry at least $10,000 in PIP and $10,000 in PDL. This ensures that everyone has at least some money to cover medical bills and damage to other people’s property.

What should I do immediately after an accident in Hollywood?

First, check for injuries. Then, move to a safe spot and call the police. Take photos of the cars, the license plates, and the street signs. Finally, call Finney Insurance so we can help you start the claims process.

Can I get my deductible back if the accident wasn’t my fault?

Yes, sometimes! This is called “subrogation.” If the other driver’s insurance admits they were at fault, they may pay your insurance company back, and your company will send you your deductible money.

Does my insurance cover me if I hit a pothole on I-95?

Hitting a pothole is usually considered a “collision” with the road. If you have Collision Coverage, your insurance can help pay for the repairs to your tires or suspension after you pay your deductible.

Why did my insurance rates go up even though I wasn’t at fault?

In Florida, rates are based on many things, including the number of accidents in your zip code. If there are thousands of crashes in Hollywood, the “risk” for everyone goes up, which can sometimes cause prices to rise for the whole community.

Conclusion: Let Finney Insurance Help You Drive with Confidence

Driving in Broward County can be a challenge, but you don’t have to face it alone. From the busy lanes of I-95 to the crowded parking lots of our favorite shopping malls, accidents are a part of life in South Florida. By understanding that most crashes are caused by things like distraction, tailgating, and hit-and-runs, you can take steps to be a more careful driver. More importantly, by choosing the right insurance—like Collision, Comprehensive, and Uninsured Motorist coverage—you can make sure that a bad day on the road doesn’t turn into a financial disaster.

Are you sure you have the right protection for the 2026 driving season? Don’t wait until after an accident to find out your coverage is missing something important. Contact Finney Insurance in Hollywood, FL today. Our team lives and works right here in your community, and we know exactly what Broward drivers need to stay safe. Call us now or visit our website for a free, friendly review of your policy!

author avatar
John Finney President
Finney Insurance Corporation was founded in 2009 by John Finney in order to purchase Stirling Insurance Services Davie location. After being the Sales Manager for Ken Finney State Farm for eight years, John Finney purchased Stirling Insurance Services which had been in business for over 20 years.He knew that he wanted to be an independent agent due to the fact of the diversity of products and companies to help people, and because his potential was not limited. In short, John and his staff were tired of telling people “Sorry I can not help you”. Ken Finney’s office was closed in 2010 after 34 years of serving the community’s insurance needs due to State Farm stating they were pulling out of the state for homeowners insurance. Finney Insurance Corporation moved into Ken’s old location and hired most of his employees.It was a very difficult task to undertake without having all of the State Farm business, as it was given to other State Farm agents. Today that struggle and decision has paid off. Finney Insurance Corporation now has been growing at an incredible rate because of its diversity in an ever changing marketplace and its neighborhood agency feel for its clients. All of Finney Insurance’s staff are experienced professionals some with over 25 years in the industry. They care about the companies they represent and their customers. We are also proud members of the Hollywood Chamber of Commerce and Latin American Association of Insurance Agencies. The Finney family has been involved in the community for 34 years and plan to continue to support the community with our agency. We also want to increase our services to our clients through technology and knowledge of new insurance concepts. Once we have fully realized our potential in our current location we would like to expand to other locations in Florida through acquisitions. Our marketing, referrals, cross sales, and bond with clients is our real strength and source of increased business to date and will continue in the future. We feel by aligning ourselves with quality companies we can be successful in a mutually beneficial relationship and provide the highest quality and selection for our customers to help them with all of their insurance needs; instead saying, “Yes, we can help you with that!”
Scroll to Top
Skip to content